It’s not every day that you first hear about a comedian through their fiancée, but that’s exactly what happened here. When I tell you that the fiancée in question was Jessie Cave, who mentioned him in her fabulous 2018 Fringe show Sunrise, hopefully you can see why it stuck in our memory.
So there we were, tickets in hand (okay, on our phones!), heading to that stalwart of Edinburgh comedy, The Stand. But before we get to that, I need to tell you about the wonderful weekend of drinks we’d enjoyed in the lead-up to this point. Partly to recommend some incredible venues, but mostly so you truly understand what it means when I say that we needed every single drop of that alcohol to deal with the hour that followed!
In no particular order, we begin with our friends at Cocktail Geeks. The current theme is Clue, with all the drinks based around criminals or detectives and challenges accompanying each one. It’s a lot of fun, and both ‘The Last Laugh’ and ‘Dragon of Dojima’ excelled in task and taste.
We also visited both of the Lind & Lime and Port of Leith sister distilleries. The latter for the view, the former to try their new Valencia orange gin, which is top notch. And whilst wandering around the area, we actually stumbled across the Old Poison micro-distillery. Excellent drinks, an amazing concept and some great vibes from their bar on Portland Place.
For most people, that would probably be enough… but we are not most people! We actually started one day at the Roseleaf in Leith, where we had a truly amazing brunch, followed by one of their pot-tails (a sharing cocktail served in a teapot, obviously). We opted for Rhubarb & Custard and cannot recommend it highly enough.
Lastly, we have to talk about our trip to Skoll & Hati. The Viking-themed bar never disappoints, and drinking our way through the menu change from day to night (or Skoll to Hati) was an absolute pleasure. The Jormungandr is still my personal favourite, but I don’t think there’s a bad cocktail in the place… and trust me, we tested thoroughly.
So, with that out of the way, and our context firmly in place, on with the show.
The Stand had pulled in a solid crowd for this particular evening. The main stage area was fully sold out, with a little spillage into the back and sides. Not quite a completely sold-out room, but by no means sparse.
Our clown took to the stage as his own warm-up act. We have no idea whether this was down to budget, ticket sales or a last-minute cancellation, but one thing was clear: this wasn’t by choice. Alfie had nothing prepared for this segment and really didn’t seem inclined to try. He bantered a little with some chatty women in the front row (fuelled by prosecco and pickled Monster Munch), discovered that another chap was on an obligatory second stag do with his future in-laws, and even had a Scottish African Safari Explorer sitting right in front of the mic. In most clowns’ hands, this would be comedy gold… but not if you can’t be bothered.
You see, as Alfie explained, this was an obligatory tour date. Anyone who actually liked him in this part of the world would have come to see the show a couple of months earlier at the Fringe, so this was simply an audience that wouldn’t understand his comedy.
Anyway, to close out the ‘warm-up’, he promised that we were in for an amazing show when he returned to the stage. A couple of people weren’t convinced and left, but we knew better. Why, just the other week we’d seen a clown kill a show after a lukewarm introductory act, and this was the much-lauded Chortle Best Show winner, Alfie Brown. This was going to be good.
Only it wasn’t… and our clown had decided that it was our fault.
He butchered the delivery of his punchlines, chastised us for not laughing loudly enough and then proceeded to explain the jokes to us because we were clearly too stupid (or apparently ‘left’) to understand them.
The worst thing was that there was some truly great material in this show, screaming to get out. His twist on our perceptions of, and therefore fair expectations of, Trump was clever. The routine around his dog’s political views was funny. And the bit about his testosterone use and its effects on his penis was… well, no, actually, that was just weird, but somewhat fascinating given that it was the only part of his set where he appeared excitedly animated.
And on we went, with punchlines and material being wasted, while our clown reacted to every single rustling crisp packet as if someone had dropped the N-word (oh, sorry Alfie!). This was awkwardness at its finest, only further enhanced by our clown stopping the set every so often to announce, ‘I’m having fun, this is a fun gig, aren’t we all having fun?’
The show ended with us walking out in silence (Alfie had decided that we didn’t deserve music, so asked them not to play any) and heading home, trying to figure out what had just happened. Was he trying to do a bit of a Stewart Lee but had simply forgotten to be funny? Was he going for angry-clown energy but couldn’t quite commit?
Normally, we wouldn’t bother discussing a disappointing performance at such length, but we genuinely know that this clown is funny. People whose opinions I trust and respect – friends, clowns and critics – have recommended his work.
But all we can do is talk about our experience on this particular night, and that was of an obviously intelligent, eloquent and confident performer who just could not be bothered to entertain.
Clown Stars: * *
@The Stand, Edinburgh
N.B. The blackboard at The Stand actually had the show title spelt incorrectly. I now can’t help wondering if it was just some really clever foreshadowing on their part.


Leave a Reply