We came here tonight excited to see The Dark Room’s John Robertson take to the stage without his Christmas-tree-light-adorned shoulder pads! In fact, it was the very reason we actually booked the tickets… obviously. As you can probably guess from the title, that plan didn’t quite come to fruition.

Now, we have no idea why the headliner changed, but with mixed-bill nights, it’s all about how the situation is handled. And in this instance, it was handled by bringing in one of the Edinburgh Fringe’s great comedy mainstays and the winner of ITV’s Show Me the Funny, Patrick Monahan.

We’re still not quite sure how compere extraordinaire Keith Farnan manages to keep pulling these fantastic acts into a 60-seater pub back room in Harrow on the Hill, but we’re both impressed and very thankful that he does. He must know where pretty much every comedy skeleton is buried!

Anyway, on to this evening’s show. It was a truly cold night in North London, which made the bright lights and cosy vibes of the Castle pub feel even more warm and welcoming than usual. We headed in, ordered a couple of large gins (local pubs never seem to call them doubles?) and wandered into the venue to find some seats.

We’re getting close to the start time, but there’s still no sign of our clown host. Then, suddenly, he appears, resplendent in his Christmas scarf and looking thoroughly frazzled from whatever had made him late (an entertaining tale that becomes a fantastically frenetic opening set).

A mix of cheers and people shouting ‘Keeeeith!’ takes over the room. I can only describe it as a more excitable version of Norm’s entrance in Cheers. You see, these are true regulars to this night, and over the years that relationship has become so much more than host and punter.

Whilst Keith gets the room ready – the new pub manager hadn’t actually set anything up, other than chairs – he gets chatting to the crowd and finds gold in the second row in the form of newcomer Katie, a retired drama teacher who could quite happily have worked as Dame Judi Dench’s stunt double. By chatting to her, he entertains the room while setting up, before launching into his opening tale and, as if it was all going exactly to plan, introducing the first act.

As Eleanor Tiernan gets up to speed, I find it shocking that we haven’t come across her work before. This is an incredibly natural and accomplished clown with some great material around aging and involuntary celibacy. She cruised through her opening act, only enhancing the energy that Keith had already built in the room – We’ve never seen a full routine about a speculum before – eye-opening, to say the least!

Next to step up to the hearth (this room really doesn’t have a stage; the closest would be the base of the fireplace… not that anyone actually performs there either) is relative newcomer Danika Thibalt, a Canuck clown with more energy than a beaver on maple syrup! It’s always interesting to see a clown bring a totally different vibe to the room (in this case, ‘Woo-Hoo!’ would describe it best), but the combination of a positive comedy community and some really well-thought-out jokes makes this a great addition to the bill. It seems Danika has a great 15 minutes and is working on taking it to 45. We’d definitely like to see it when she gets there.

And last, but by no means least, we have our headliner, Patrick Monahan. Like Russell Hicks and Carl Donnelly before him, it’s truly impressive how these clowns, who have won major awards, released their own DVDs and regularly appeared on TV, seem to leave their egos at the door and play this weirdly lit back room in exactly the same way they’d approach a far bigger show. The lack of ego is something other industries should aspire to.

Our headliner clown turns to the crowd for the majority of his material, spinning hilarious routines out of the seemingly most innocuous interactions. He charms the room in seconds, entertains constantly and sails past his time allocation, as he’s often known to do – not that anyone is at all disappointed.

This is cosy comedy at its finest. At the end of the gig, the acts can be found happily in the bar chatting with audience members. Keith Farnan really has created something special here. It will never be the biggest event, but the community he’s built around it is something very special indeed.

Clown Stars: * * * *

@Castle Comedy Club, HotH, London


Tickets to the next Castle Comedy gig are available now, and if you enjoyed this review then you may like to read about our past adventures at The Castle Comedy Club…